104: How to Really Hear Your Inner Critic

Your inner critic is just another part of you, but often, we don’t actually acknowledge our inner critic. It’s like background music that we try to tune out, but it ends up weighing us down. So, what can you do to really hear your inner critic without it stopping you in your tracks? Listen in this week to find out.

Really hearing your inner critic requires an understanding of one important tool: un-blending. Un-blending is the skill of going from first to second-person listening when hearing the voice of your inner critic. Giving you the objectivity and space that you need to stop falling victim to your negative inner monologue.

Tune in this week to discover how to zoom out and get some perspective when listening to your inner critic. I’m sharing how understanding Internal Family Systems (IFS) can transform how you interact with your inner critic, and I’m giving you a valuable exercise to stop your inner critic from keeping you stuck.

Habits on Purpose with Kristi Angevine | How to Really Hear Your Inner Critic

Your inner critic is just another part of you, but often, we don’t actually acknowledge our inner critic. It’s like background music that we try to tune out, but it ends up weighing us down. So, what can you do to really hear your inner critic without it stopping you in your tracks? Listen in this week to find out.

Habits on Purpose with Kristi Angevine | How to Really Hear Your Inner Critic

Really hearing your inner critic requires an understanding of one important tool: un-blending. Un-blending is the skill of going from first to second-person listening when hearing the voice of your inner critic. Giving you the objectivity and space that you need to stop falling victim to your negative inner monologue.

Tune in this week to discover how to zoom out and get some perspective when listening to your inner critic. I’m sharing how understanding Internal Family Systems (IFS) can transform how you interact with your inner critic, and I’m giving you a valuable exercise to stop your inner critic from keeping you stuck.

To get on the waitlist for the next Habits on Purpose for Physicians group coaching program and to be the first to hear about our next start date in 2024, click here!

If you’re interested in connecting with me for private coaching, I do keep a small panel of private clients and I love helping them explore their minds and explore their habits so they can make real shifts in their lives. To get more information, click here!

What you'll learn from this episode:

  • How the voice of your inner critic keeps you stuck.
  • My experience of a constantly running negative inner monologue.
  • An exercise for listening to your inner critic while also giving it some space.
  • Why your inner critic is a product of your thoughts, and your thoughts are not objective facts.
  • What this process of un-blending looks like and why this work matters.
  • How to use un-blending in your everyday life, so you can access your wise, compassionate, authentic self.

Listen to the Full Episode:

Powerful Takeaways:

03:38 “I’m going to tell you what this exercise is and exactly how to do it.”

06:50 “So often, we don’t recognize our thoughts as thoughts.”

11:45 “IFS calls this process of getting space from your thoughts or emotions un-blending.”

13:28 “You get space from those thoughts and space from the feelings that those thoughts invoke.”

19:07 “Parts, when we are fully blended with them, they are reality-makers. They can seem like just who we are. But the truth is…”

Featured on the Show:

Related Episodes:

Full Episode Transcript:

Welcome to Episode 104. I'm your host, Kristi Angevine, and I am here to help you understand why you do what you do, so you can live your life on purpose instead of on autopilot.

In today's episode, I'm talking about un-blending, and how to notice your sneaky, inner critical voice. What's it mean to unblend? Take a listen and find out.

Welcome to Habits On Purpose, a podcast for high-achieving women who want to create lifelong habits that give more than they take. You'll get practical strategies for mindset shifts that will help you finally understand the root causes of why you think, feel, and act as you do. And now, here's your host, Physician, and Master Certified Life Coach, Kristi Angevine.

Hello, hello, everybody. Today, I'm going to teach you a really fun and simple tool for noticing your inner critic, and getting some objectivity and space from this. And while this is particularly useful for an inner critic, AKA your inner critical part, it works with other parts as well.

Now, this is a really near and dear topic for me. It's important for me to teach because for a long time, I had a really negative inner running monologue. And I really didn't acknowledge it. I kind of wasn't even aware it was there; it was like background music that I didn't know was playing. But it weighed me down.

It would show up in all sorts of sneaky ways. I imagine you can probably relate to this. In the background, I would have a running, very harsh, negative inner commentary. What would occur in my life is I would procrastinate. I wouldn't speak up, or I would stay quiet, even though I wanted to say something. I would not take risks. I might not email somebody.

I wouldn't want to take action on ideas for fear that they would reveal my inescapable ineptitudes to the world. And it would drive a lot of my second guessing, as well as guilt over things that seemed really huge but in hindsight were really minutiae.

So, what I'm going to teach you today is something really practical. It's similar to what you might do in meditation, where you notice your thoughts and feelings, and you observe them with a little bit of space. In meditation, that might sound like, “Oh, I notice I'm having a thought.”

It might sound like reminding yourself that you're separate from that thought, or separate from the feeling that you notice. In meditation, this gives you perspective and objectivity. That's the same thing I'm going to teach you today, but with a different tool.

Getting perspective and objectivity is the equivalent of being in the forest of trees and experiencing a thick jungle, versus having the vantage point of a drone observing the jungle or the forest, and also being able to see the entire landscape around the forest.

So, while the tool I'm going to teach you today is very simple, and it's commonly taught in many cognitive behavioral approaches, there's a fascinating complexity to how and why it works, that can enhance our understanding of it and that comes from the field of Internal Family Systems.

I'm going to teach you how to do the exercise. I'm going to tell you why this exercise is useful. And then, we'll get into some of the mechanics of how it works using the concepts and terminology from the Internal Family Systems, or IFS model.

Now, you can use this tool without understanding the how and the why it works. But if you're like me, you might love knowing the way it works, and it might actually make it easier to apply it when you have this understanding. So, what is this exercise I keep talking about? I'm going to tell you what the exercise is and exactly how to do it. And then, we'll elaborate on why it's important.

This is called the “first to second person” exercise. In this context, we're using it to detect your inner critic. So, take out a sheet of paper, or get out your computer, or whatever you like to take notes on. It's key, the first time you do this, that you actually externalize things. That you don't just do it in your mind.

So, if you're driving down the road, and you are going to be commuting for the next three hours, and you really, really, really, really must try this before you get to a sheet of paper or before you get to your computer, totally fine. But ideally, you want to do this where you can actually externalize things from your mind.

Write down all the negative commentary that you hear in your mind that comes in the first person. It might sound like, “I'm not cut out for this. I suck. I'm always struggling. Everyone else has more put together than me. I'm such an idiot. I'm never going to get it. I failed. I didn't handle things like I should have.”

What you're looking for are thoughts that are first person statements; they're a little bit critical, a little bit harsh, a little bit negative. So, you write those down, and I kind of like to write them in a column on one side of the paper and then have a corresponding column next to them.

What you do in this corresponding column, with each statement, convert all of them to the second person. Notice how they sound. Consider how it would feel to have someone else telling these statements to you. And, consider how it would be to say them aloud to another person.

So it sounds like this, “Maybe I'm not cut out for this,” turns into, “Maybe you're not cut out for this.” “I suck,” turns into, “You really suck.” “I'm such an idiot,” turns into, “You're such an idiot.” See how they sound kind of harsh when you put them in the second person? Notice that you might actually physically wince when you imagine someone saying them to you or you saying them aloud to another person.

The next step is to take a moment and consider an alternate statement for each one, one that's more neutral, more objective, and perhaps even a little kinder. So, let's take, “I'm never going to get this.” We convert it to a second person statement, and it is, “You're never going to get this.” A more neutral or impartial statement might sound like, “This is hard. But we can break this down into smaller steps. It's possible. You can get this. Maybe it just looks differently than I originally thought.”

Now, your alternate statements, they can be in second person or first person, whatever feels more natural to you. So, write down first person negative statements, convert them to second person statements, notice how they feel, imagine hearing them from someone else or saying them to someone else, and then find an alternative, neutral statement. Simple enough, right?

So, why do this? Like I said in Episode 102, inner work is not just indulgent or avoidant of “real” work. Inner work is actually the most effective, most foundational work that you can do to assist you in doing the work that you want to do out in the world.

But why do this exercise specifically? Number one, so often we don't recognize our thoughts as thoughts. We experience our thoughts as mere observation of the world around us and ourselves. And we assume that the words going through our mind are simply objective, rational, and true.

When you do ‘first to the second person’, it helps you see what you're telling yourself, that you presume, are simply observations of reality. In this way, this exercise is a narrative finder.

Number two, we don't recognize the tone of our thoughts. We sometimes don't realize how harsh or negative or rigid or mean they are. We also might not notice if they're entitled or pitying. Imagining someone outside of you saying these thoughts to you reveals the tone really fast.

Number three, it helps identify an inner critic that might be stealthy. Oftentimes, when we read about inner critics, it's common parlance to describe it as a ‘voice or running narrative’ that's in the second person. Sounds like, “You suck. You're dumb. No one likes you. You're such an idiot. You can't hold a conversation with anyone.”

This might be in your own voice, or it could sound like a parent, a sibling, a schoolmate, or this amalgamation of cultural messages. But for some of us, we don't hear the second person voice that is easier to distinguish. Or we do hear second person voice, but there's also another voice that's just as negative, but it's in the first person.

It sounds like, “I suck. What is my problem? Why on earth should I say that? I have no idea what I'm doing. Everyone else can handle it, what's wrong with me?” The first person thoughts are so intimately close that we can mistake them for being the ‘true’ us. They're like a lens, through which we're looking, that we can't see because it's totally clear.

It's always there, but we're not far enough away from it to see it. Just like contact lenses, or a really, really clean windshield. First person “I” statements are more likely to be experienced as reality, when they're simply virtual reality goggles.

So, check out this example. Say you're sitting in a coffee shop and you're enjoying your drink, you're reading, and an acquaintance of yours... Let's just make up a name... Jill, walks in. You go say hi to Jill, you'll have some back-and-forth small chat, and in walks another acquaintance… who we’ll just call Stephanie. These names are just made up, by the way, so forgive me if there's any Jill's or Stephanie's out there.

You say, “Jill, do you know Stephanie?” They both share, “Oh, yeah, we see each other all the time at work.” In that moment, you realize that they both work at the same place, and you feel this wave of embarrassment and self-consciousness. Because you know that they work at the same place, but you forgot.

Jill and Stephanie, they chuckle, Stephanie asked how you're both doing, and the small talk just keeps going. But you're pretty sure that Jill and Stephanie have a flash of an expression that goes across their faces, that betrays that they both think you're weird and dense and dumb for not knowing that they work together and for introducing them when they already know each other.

It was so brief that you conclude that they're now just being diplomatic, but behind their friendliness, they secretly think that you're stupid. In your mind, you're thinking, “What the hell? Of course, they know each other. I am so dumb. How embarrassing. Oh Fuck, they hate me. They're only being nice because we're in public. And later they’re going to talk about what a dumbass I am.”

In the moment, you feel terrible. Yet, you hide it with small talk, and eventually excuse yourself from the conversation with some fake excuse that you have to get going when you really don't.

Now, the lived experience is first person commentary, in your mind, and intense feelings of embarrassment and anxiety. But if we could press pause and everyone in the coffee shop froze but you, and say, a wise friend or a coach, we could look back and see that in the moment of making an introduction to people who actually work together and already know one another, a part of you comes in, comes online, and offers you thoughts like, “I'm so dumb. They hate me,” etc.

When we convert those thoughts to second person we can see them more clearly. “You are so dumb. They clearly hate you. Later, they're going to talk about you behind your back. What an idiot, you can't do anything, right.” Although your lived experience isn't you hearing it in second person, when you think those thoughts like ‘I'm dumb,’ and you believe it, it's the equivalent of telling yourself you’re dumb, just like somebody else saying you're dumb.

When you convert it to second person, it helps you with a few things. It helps you see that automatic, harsh, mean way you treat yourself in the moment. It's likely not how you would talk to someone else unless you're really disgusted or mad at them.

The second person exercise helps you create space and perspective. Second person helps you retrospectively appreciate your thoughts as thoughts, and not as purely objective observations.

Internal Family Systems, or IFS, calls this process of getting space from your thoughts, emotions, or the parts that are present and online, “un-blending.” You can understand un-blending by thinking of what happens when you drop a drop of food coloring into water or milk. Or what happens when you put on sunglasses and you see the world through that lens.

When your thoughts are so intimately close, otherwise known as ‘when a part of you is blended with you,’ you see the world through that part’s eyes, and you experience the world through that part’s lens; with that part’s values, that part’s thoughts, that part’s emotions.

When you unblend from this part, what's happening is you're separating yourself from the part, just like separating molecules of dye and milk. I don't know if that's even possible, the chemistry people out there can tell me if I'm just making up a terrible analogy. Or just like taking off a pair of sunglasses.

So, try it. Write down critical thoughts you have of yourself. Perhaps think back to an incident where you felt really terrible. What were you telling yourself? What thoughts were in your mind, in the first person? Write them in one column, in the other column write down the second person version, and just contrast the two.

Notice how, when you put them in second person, a lot of the comments really sting. When you see first person thoughts and second person thoughts, it's easier to access compassion and curiosity. And these are, frankly, the silver bullets for almost all of our struggles.

So, now let's just go a little deeper into the mechanics of what's going on when you notice your thoughts as thoughts. When you notice a part of you is being critical. And when you notice that you are blended with a part. Along the way, you're going to hear how it helps with perspective, compassion, and curiosity.

When you notice and get space from your thoughts, it might sound like, “Oh, a part of me is thinking,” X-Y-Z. And when you do that, you get space from those thoughts and space from the feelings those thoughts invoke. But here's the question, who is getting space from those thoughts and feelings? Who's getting space from that part? What's present when the part separates from you?

To explain this requires that we visit the concept of Self, with a capital S, which is perhaps one of the harder concepts in IFS to really understand and frankly, to accept. Self, with a capital S, is a state of being where we feel things like clarity, compassion, playfulness, curiosity, and calm. It may also be characterized by confidence, feeling creative, and feeling connected.

Self is who you are when you are most you. It's your seat of consciousness that's unfettered by cognitive distortions and limiting beliefs. Self is the birthplace of inner wisdom, of knowing, intuition, and it's the core, wise version of you that can compassionately, confidently navigate anything. It's your authentic self.

So, to use the language of parts, when parts step back, when we get distance from thoughts, our inner critic, feelings, emotions, parts, Self… with a capital S… spontaneously emerges. Meaning, when you get space from a critical voice, and can see it as a part of you, or a cluster of opinions as opposed to objective reality, you can gain access to feeling curious, calm, and clear. You gain access to this authentic you.

The analogy that I really love is one of clouds in the sun. When the sky is cloudy, you can't see the sun, you can't see the blue sky, but they're there. When the clouds move, you can see the sky and the sun. So, imagine that your critical thoughts, or the part of you that's critical, are the clouds. And Self, with a capital S, is the sky or the sun.

Self is always there, but it can be obscured by the presence of parts, or when parts are blended. When you get space from the critical part, then you can access the state of being where you are calm, have curiosity, have compassion, have clarity, have perspective. Which is analogous to the clouds parting and seeing the sky, or seeing the sun, and having access to both.

So, when you do the first to second person exercise, you're giving yourself a chance to unblended from parts and access your true Self. And here's the brilliance of doing this. When you can do it with an exercise on paper, you actually learn two additional things: You learn the difference of what it feels like when you're blended with a part, versus when you're connected to your true, wise, calm Self. And knowing this difference helps you notice when other parts are present.

You can tell the difference between parts, as opposed to Self being present, when you feel anything other than these qualities that start with a letter C. If you're not feeling Curious, Calm, Creative, Clear, Connected, Courageous or Compassionate, that means there's the presence of a part.

And when you know how to unblend using an exercise on paper, you actually learn how to do the process in the real world, off the page, which is where real change and where all the magic happens. So, when you're in everyday life you can start to notice: Am I feeling more of this Self energy; these qualities of Self, with a capital S, that start with a C? Or am I feeling something else?

If I'm feeling something else, I can use the language of parts and say, “A part of me feels tense. A part of me feels sad. A part of me feels disappointed. A part of me is thinking, ‘I'm such a loser.’ A part is overwhelmed. A part is running my to-do list right now and second guessing.”

The simple act of naming a part can start the process of getting space from that part, which is the equivalent of removing goggles and seeing the world through a different lens.

Now, word to the wise, Self is not superior to parts; parts are not a problem. Therefore, the absence of parts, and 100% embodying or connecting to this thing we're calling Self is not actually the goal. The goal is simply to notice and create space so there's room for both. And ultimately, to create this collaborative vibe between the parts of ourselves and between Self. Like you might have between a great coach and a great team, where neither can exist in a vacuum but they collaborate together.

The next caveat, distinguishing parts from Self is not always totally straightforward, which is why this exercise is really useful and makes it really practical. But if, when you're doing it, it doesn't feel super easy to you, that's totally normal. First of all, this is a new way of approaching your mind and emotions that no one taught us in school.

Secondly, sometimes parts of us have qualities of Self. A part that's angry might have lots of confidence and clarity. But the difference is, a part can feel indignant and wronged and pissed off, but Self won't feel those things. It'll just feel confident and clear.

Or an anxious part might seem really curious because it asks the questions: What am I going to do next? How’s this possibly going to work? What's that mean? An anxious part might actually fuel a certain flavor of creativity, of thinking about all sorts of things and putting things together.

But an anxious part is going to have an agenda, scarcity, be in a hurry, and have some angst. Versus Self, where that curiosity and creativity won't be fueled by this inner angst or agenda or scarcity.

Additionally, and this is kind of mind bending, some parts of us just seem like who we are; intrinsic to us as a person and intrinsic to our personality. Sounds like, “I'm just a type-A person. I'm just really detail oriented. I've always been perfectionistic. It's just the way I am, to see the worst-case scenario.”

Parts, when we are fully blended with them, they are reality makers. And parts that we've had for decades can seem like just who we are. But the truth is, they're actually a distinct part, different from the Self qualities. The fun, and the challenge, is in detecting them.

So, to review, unblending is the process of noticing thoughts, noticing emotions, or noticing a part of you is present and getting space from it so that you can access more of your wise, calm, compassionate, authentic self.

Self, is a state of being that Internal Family Systems describes as your true you, that you experience when your parts have pulled back and given you some space. Using the first and second person exercise gives you the space to notice your critical part, and it also works with other parts too.

Learning the skill of unblending and practicing it regularly is a skill you can cultivate in all areas of life, and it has no downside. Also remember, parts can be challenging to distinguish from Self, and parts are not superior to Self.

So, I invite you to try this exercise today and become your own parts detector. And while you're at it, notice how you can shift from this insidious flogging from your inner critic to having more of a middle road neutral perspective. Until next week, I will see you soon.

If you're a woman physician who wants to quit feeling like you're living at the effect of circumstances like a leaf in the wind, and you're ready to change unintentional habits to intentional ones, you're going to want to go to HabitsOnPurpose.com/waitlist right now.

When you do, you can sign up to be the first to hear about all the updates and enrollment information for the next round of my small group coaching program, that's called HOPP, Habits on Purpose for Physicians.

HOPP is a small group of women physicians who work on unpacking habits like being perpetually busy, being always behind on charts, overworking, second guessing, beating yourself up, people pleasing, ruminating, or numbing with all the things; food, alcohol, shopping, screentime, etc.

The program is really incredible, because it gives you an intimate community of like-minded physicians working on similar life challenges. Whether it's self-doubt as a leader, perfectionism, or getting triggered at work or with your spouse or with your parenting, in HOPP you learn practical tools to help you understand why you do what you do so you can start doing something else.

The next round begins in February of 2024, and comes with CME. So, go to HabitsOnPurpose.com/waitlist today.

Thanks for listening to Habits On Purpose. If you want more information on Kristi Angevine or the resources from the podcast, visit HabitsOnPurpose.com. Tune in next week for another episode.

Enjoy the show: